Don't Know Dickens

Charles Dickens, that is.

Edwin Drood’s Big Finish

  • Edwin is dead.
  • Mr. Grewgious killed him.
  • Grewgious knows more than he shares with the other characters. And he wanted the ring to preserve the memory of his love for Rosa’s mother.
  • Grewgious is ticked that Drood did not take pursue the girl (who looks soooo much like her  mother) while Drood has the opportunity and the means.
  • Jasper was not a loving uncle, but he has problems that are not quite private.
  • He is being set up. Others know about his love for Rosa and his opium problem.
  • The whole town is dark, corrupt, and full of mystery–why not spread the distrust to more than the obvious character?
  • Jasper doesn’t find Drood’s watch and shirtpin; Crisparkle does–for good reasons. 
  • Rosa does not marry. She realizes that she, in fact, loves Edwin.
  • She spends her days in the nunnery as she tries to recover from Jasper’s rape. (Come on, he meets her in a garden and makes advances against her will. He penetrates her space emotionally, if not physically.)
  • Princess Puffer breaks Jasper because he does not know what happened, most likely because of his hallucinations. She blackmails him until he believes that he has committed the crime.
  • Durdles? Well, Durdles finds the body, but I’m not sure who takes the blame (although it is clear to the reader who killed Drood).
  • Jasper may take the blame (with the suggestion given to him by Princess Puffer), but he is never sure of the events of that night.

Single Post Navigation

2 thoughts on “Edwin Drood’s Big Finish

  1. dickensinthelibrary on said:

    I love your observation that Mr. Grewgious may have killed Edwin Drood. Grewgious does know more of the comings and goings of all the characters and he is a great suspect. I do not think it is so simple as John Jasper or Neville Landless; I think it is far more complicated and that Dickens would have kept us guessing until the end, had he lived to finish the novel.

  2. Exactly! The book is only half finished–why should the obvious choice (Jasper) be the correct one when we have so much of the story remaining?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: